Current Events and Issues

Mitigating the risk and impact of assaults on EMS responders

Posted: Jan. 13, 2020

The SAVER checklist helps departments assess and implement training, policies and practices to mitigate assaults on EMS responders.

Many studies have shown that firefighters and emergency medical services (EMS) responders have a high likelihood of experiencing verbal or physical violence at least once in their career. Fire-based paramedics and EMS are at particularly high risk of experiencing an assault since they respond to calls in varied locations, often paired with only one or two colleagues. In these situations, they may come into close contact with people who have mental health issues.

Researchers on the Stress and Violence to Fire-based EMS Responders (SAVER) study found many improvements organizations can make to mitigate the risk and impact of assaults on their responders. High-reliability organizations — those that have fewer than normal accidents, such as the airline and healthcare industries — have mitigated risks through the adoption of systems-level, organizational checklists.

SAVER study researchers wanted to develop a systems-level checklist for violence against fire-based EMS responders using findings from a comprehensive literature review. They also gathered input from subject matter experts at a national stakeholder meeting.

What the research shows

Prevention opportunities exist when we look as far upstream as possible from the likely source of harm. Therefore, it's best to focus on organizational policies that can shape solutions before the problem occurs.

When management and unions can put effective policies in place, responsibility for safety is firmly on the organization rather than on the individual EMS responder. This is important since management organizes training opportunities and establishes standard operating procedures that can minimize the risk.

Organizational-level checklist

The final SAVER checklist consists of 174 items organized by six phases of EMS response:

  1. Pre-event.
  2. Traveling to the scene.
  3. Scene arrival.
  4. Patient care.
  5. Assessing readiness to return to service.
  6. Post-event.

The organization, not individual EMS responders, is responsible for nearly all the 174 checklist items. Fire departments and labor unions can use the checklist to accurately assess and implement training, policies and practices that promote the prevention and mitigation of assaults on EMS responders. Organizations can provide training to their personnel to recognize and react appropriately to potentially dangerous situations by using “pause-points” to protect their health and safety while on calls.

While the checklist is organizational in implementation, the result impacts the individual worker.

SAVER study researchers

Individual-level checklist: pause points

EMS responders focus on a six-item individual-level checklist, also referred to as “pause points.” Department-level training provides EMS responders with the knowledge of how to call a safety “time-out” at one of six specific pause points.

  • Traveling to the scene: If you know there has been violence at a location in the past, request and wait for law enforcement backup.
  • Scene arrival: Before exiting the ambulance, are all the resources you need in place to safely begin patient care?
  • Patient care: Before transport, does your patient require restraint and have they been checked for weapons?
  • Assessing readiness to return to service: Are you mentally and physically ready to return to service?
  • Post-event (reporting): If you have experienced verbal or physical violence, have you reported it?
  • Post-event (resources): Have you sought and received the physical and long-term mental health resources you feel will enable you to return to work whole and ready?

These six individual-level actions give EMS responders the organizational mandate to protect themselves while providing vital patient care. They also put into place a feedback mechanism to management on what might not be working in the field.

Learn more about this research

Summary information for this article was provided by the NETC Library. Read the research paper.

Taylor, J. A., Murray, R. M., Davis, A. L., Shepler, L. J., Harrison, C. K., Novinger, N. A., & Allen, J. A. (2019). Creation of a Systems-Level Checklist to Address Stress and Violence in Fire-Based Emergency Medical Services Responders. Occupational Health Science, 3(3), 265–295. doi: 10.1007/s41542-019-00047-z

More content on the web

This research was supported by a Fire Prevention and Safety Grant (Research and Development) Grant under the Federal Emergency Management Agency's FY2016 Assistance to Firefighters Grant Program (EMW-2016-FP-00277). Learn more about this project.

This summary is for informational purposes only. As such, the content does not reflect any official positions, policies, or guidelines on behalf of the sender, the U.S. Fire Administration, FEMA, DHS, nor any other federal agencies, departments or contracting entities. Similarly, this summary does not represent in any manner an official endorsement or relationship to any private or public companies, organizations/associations, or any authors or individuals cited or websites associated within the article.

  • Filter:
graphic examples
NEW
New graphics highlight wildland firefighter safety messaging

Graphics for wildland firefighters that depict the 10 Standard Firefighting Orders and 18 Watch Out Situations are available for download.

woman wearing a mask during a wildfire
Minimizing the effects of wildfire smoke during COVID-19

Inform your community about these actionable steps they can take to minimize the respiratory effects of wildfire smoke.

photo of an activated residential fire sprinkler head
Retrofitting homes with lower cost sprinkler technologies

USFA is working with the UL Firefighter Safety Research Institute on research to reduce home fire sprinkler retrofit complexities.

photo of person installing gutter guards
Doing the little things makes a difference in wildfire safety

Learn about simple and low-cost actions that homeowners can take to protect their homes from wildfire.

photo of a burned out room
First responders: know your fire investigation role

This year's Arson Awareness Week (May 3-9) highlights the crucial role that first responders can play in a successful fire investigation.

photo of a marina
Fire onboard: safety tips for boaters in your community

Resources you can use to make people in boating communities aware of onboard fire dangers and how to prevent boat and marina fires.

burned out street after a wildfire with street signs propped up
WUI fire evacuations: how national address point data helps

A national address point database can be of value to officials during wildfire evacuations by allowing for more precise mapping and improved information sharing.

paramedics placing a patient into an ambulance
Mitigating the risk and impact of assaults on EMS responders

The SAVER checklist helps departments assess and implement training, policies and practices to mitigate assaults on EMS responders.

courtroom
Helping assaulted first responders during legal prosecutions

Recommendations to overcome common obstacles to the legal prosecution of people who assault first responders.

doctor looking at test results
How organizational factors affect firefighter cancer screening

Having two or more health and safety officers influences the availability of firefighter cancer screening.

family making a fire escape plan
Teach your community about the dangers of fire

A recent survey shows that many in your community probably don't understand the life-threatening risks from heat and toxic smoke produced in a modern home fire.

paramedics treating an older patient at home
Community paramedics helpful in treating home-bound patients

A community paramedicine program, integrated with an advanced illness management program, can be effective in treating frail, older adults in their homes.

wildfire threatens home
Mitigating wildfire vulnerability: one community's success story

Learn how the Montecito Fire Protection District used a socio-ecological mitigation approach to successfully fight the Thomas Fire.

President Trump at the ceremony
Medal of Valor ceremony recognizes two Kansas firefighters

U.S. Fire Administrator Keith Bryant attended the Public Safety Officer Medal of Valor ceremony at the White House on May 22, 2019.

a man doing a push-up
Assessing cardiovascular disease risk with push-ups

Can a simple exercise like a push-up be an inexpensive way for fire departments to assess cardiovascular disease risk in firefighters?

graphene
Using nanotechnology to minimize fire damage

Nanotechnology, manufactured at scale and low cost while posing minimal health risks, may potentially point to a future with fewer fires that are less lethal and less damaging.

electric car and solar panels
A better DC hot stick technology is on the way

New tool will help prevent first responder electrical injury.

hoarded items in a home
Takeaways from a hoarding intervention strategy

A recent study of the City of Vancouver’s Hoarding Action Response Team provides key takeaways for fire departments.

firefighter gear
Firefighter decon challenges? Try a communication intervention.

Learn about a communication intervention strategy designed by researchers to increase post-fire decontamination behaviors in firefighters.

firefighters removing gear
Firefighter decon challenges: knowledge versus practice

Understanding firefighter beliefs related to decontaminating bunker gear is an essential first step to reduce exposure risks.

fire engine and ambulance
Dual dispatch to cardiac arrest: can it save lives?

Dual dispatch of EMT-trained firefighters shortens response time and increases survival chance for out-of-hospital cardiac arrest patients.

child sleeping with mother in background
Waking children with maternal voice smoke alarms

A new study from Nationwide Children's Hospital shows that maternal voice smoke alarms are more effective in waking children than conventional tone alarms.

home with wildfire mitigation measures in place
How one homeowner saved his house from the Carr Fire

Learn about wildfire mitigation measures one California homeowner took during construction and maintained over the years to make his home fire-resilient.

wheelchair patients
EMS Mobile Integrated Health during disaster response

How one community's MIH providers assisted with patient care during severe flooding.

paramedics treating a patient
Training helps EMS workers identify human trafficking signs

Learn about the key components of a human trafficking training and awareness program for EMS workers.

firefighter wearing SCBA at a house fire
Reducing airborne contaminant exposure with fireground tactics

New study provides valuable insights into fireground exposure risks and ways to mitigate them.

Facebook logo and a cordless phone
Smoke alarm messaging: Facebook ads versus phone calls

Study shows automated calls were more successful than Facebook ads in getting residents to request a free smoke alarm install.

person using the Airbnb app on a phone
Fire and life safety concerns in peer-to-peer lodging

Fire departments and communities around the U.S. are starting to recognize and address the unique fire safety concerns that peer-to-peer lodgings, like Airbnb, present.

circuit training
Circuit training impact on volunteer firefighters’ cardiovascular health

About 20 percent of volunteer firefighters meet the VO2 max fitness level recommended by NFPA 1582. So how might volunteer firefighters best improve their cardiovascular fitness? A study published this year explored how circuit training may help.

sprained knee
Mitigating fireground injury risks: Suggested interventions

Firefighting poses many hazards that come in a wide variety of work settings. A recent study focused on the scope and nature of fireground injuries to determine what steps fire departments can take to better mitigate hazards posed by certain risks.

man holding a smoke alarm in his hands
Home fire safety canvassing: Achieving better results

Planning a home canvassing event? These research-based tips can help you to win maximum neighborhood participation.

firefighters removing SCBA
Firefighter burnout and workplace safety

Are firefighters who show symptoms of burnout less likely to follow safety procedures? A team of researchers recently set out to learn if burnout impacted a firefighter’s ability to follow required safe work practices.

husband and wife using a laptop
New Firefighter Cancer Registry will help to monitor cancer incidents

The voluntary registry will include the number and type of fires each firefighter attended.

nurse, mom and her baby
Study reveals successful smoke alarm installation partnership

Find out what happened when Maricopa County, Arizona firefighters partnered with nurses from a home visiting program to get smoke alarms into homes of the “hard-to-reach.”

main street usa
Fire sprinkler tax incentives for small businesses

Fire service officials: Here’s some news that you can share with local small business owners to encourage them to install fire sprinklers.

paramedics entering a hospital with a patient
EMS prehospital documentation accuracy: Can body-worn cameras help?

This article discusses the results of a pilot study where EMS providers used body-worn cameras to see if they could help to improve the accuracy of their prehospital documentation.

binder of safety procedures
Factors that contribute to preventable firefighter deaths

A recent study highlights the importance of SOPs in preventing firefighter fatalities.

home boarded up with clear board
Clear boarding creates a ”no ply“ zone

There’s a new alternative to plywood for boarding up vacant and abandoned buildings that can help prevent arson: clear board.

firefighters walking away in PPE after a fire
Clean gear is the new badge of honor

This article looks at firefighter perceptions of dirty gear and how Palm Beach County Fire Rescue promoted organizational resilience to combat the risk of firefighter cancer from dirty gear.

firefighters in smoke
Clean your PPE and skin post-fire to reduce chemical exposure risk

Firefighting activities can lead to chemical contamination. This article presents research findings on cleaning personal protective equipment and skin to reduce chemical exposures.

drone delivering an AED
Transforming cardiac emergency care with drone delivery of AEDs

Preliminary studies suggest that medical drones may make a life-saving difference in providing emergency care to cardiac arrest patients, especially those in a rural setting.

fire station
Turnout times: How important is time of day?

Research findings from a recent study into how station design of dormitory location and the time of day of the emergency affect turnout times.

firefighters at the scene of a car accident
The effect of repeated exposure trauma on firefighters

This article details findings from a research project that studied the impact of repeated exposure trauma on firefighters.

chlorine test release
New report offers insights for emergency responders on chlorine releases

Multiagency chlorine release experiments were conducted in part to help emergency responders meet the planning, tactical and operational challenges of a catastrophic Toxic Inhalation Hazard release.