Helping assaulted first responders during legal prosecutions

New study provides recommendations that address common obstacles to the legal prosecution of first responder assault cases

Posted: Nov. 14, 2019

Share on: Twitter Facebook LinkedIn
courtroom

Occupational violence against firefighters and emergency medical services (EMS) workers is widespread. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported that about 3,500 EMS workers received hospital treatment in 2017 for injuries resulting from work-related violence.

The U.S. Fire Administration documented the causes of violence to firefighters and first responders in the 2017 guide, Mitigation of Occupational Violence to Firefighters and EMS Responders PDF 2.5 MB. More than half and sometimes as many as 93% of EMS responders reported that they had experienced verbal or physical violence at least once in their careers.

Another study in 2016 PDF 401 KB that captured interviews and focus groups with first responders injured in assaults found that many believed their attackers do not face real consequences in the judicial system for their actions. Even where state statutes define EMS as belonging to a “protected class” and assaults are subsequently charged as a felony, convictions are rare.

Seeking to explore the theme of first responder dissatisfaction with the prosecutorial process, a group of researchers looked at how first responder assault cases that come before the Philadelphia District Attorney's office are processed. Pennsylvania has a felonious assault statute to address such violence.

Research findings: common hindrances to prosecution

  1. Intent to cause bodily harm may be difficult to prove. If a patient becomes violent but has a mental illness, drug or alcohol intoxication, or some other medical condition, it may be difficult for the prosecutor to prove they intended to hurt the first responder. If there was no weapon or premeditation involved, then a felony charge is unlikely.
  2. A responder's level of investment may be insufficient. It may be difficult for a first responder to dedicate the time needed for court appearances. Their absences cause prosecutors to feel the case is not important.
  3. Some responders aren't prepared to testify in court. Responders may not be as familiar with the judicial process as prosecutors and judges think they are. Preparation before testifying in court is critical to get a satisfying outcome for the victim.
  4. Judicial sentencing discretion. Some judges may be influenced by a belief that violence against responders is just “a part of the job.” They may also be lenient on an offender since a felony conviction can have life-altering consequences. If a first-time offender appears to be someone who can be rehabilitated, that also makes a felony conviction a less desirable outcome.

Recommendations

  • Educate judges and attorneys that violence against first responders is not part of the job or something they signed up for. Explain how the violence has impacted the individual physically and psychologically.
  • Develop education and training to prepare assaulted responders for their court appearances. The district attorney's office, fire department management, and labor unions need to collaborate to make this happen.
  • Have a leave policy that supports the injured responder and makes it less difficult to prepare for and make multiple court appearances.
Our focus should remain on finding ways to prevent violence against EMS responders but these recommendations may go a long way towards making them feel protected and valued by the justice system.

Learn more about this research

Summary information for this article was provided by the NETC Library. Read the research paper.

Wright, J., Davis, A., Brandt-Rauf, S., Taylor, J. (2019). “Felony assault should stick:” assaulted EMS responders' frustration and dissatisfaction with the legal system. American Journal of Industrial Medicine: 16 August 2019.


This summary is for informational purposes only. More +
As such, the content does not reflect any official positions, policies, or guidelines on behalf of the sender, the U.S. Fire Administration, FEMA, DHS, nor any other federal agencies, departments or contracting entities. Similarly, this summary does not represent in any manner an official endorsement or relationship to any private or public companies, organizations/associations, or any authors or individuals cited or websites associated within the article.

Explore more articles:

graphene

Using nanotechnology to minimize fire damage

Posted: April 10, 2019

Nanotechnology, manufactured at scale and low cost while posing minimal health risks, may potentially point to a future with fewer fires that are less lethal and less damaging.

sprained knee

Mitigating fireground injury risks: Suggested interventions

Posted: Aug. 30, 2018

Firefighting poses many hazards that come in a wide variety of work settings. A recent study focused on the scope and nature of fireground injuries to determine what steps fire departments can take to better mitigate hazards posed by certain risks.

firefighters removing SCBA

Firefighter burnout and workplace safety

Posted: July 26, 2018

Are firefighters who show symptoms of burnout less likely to follow safety procedures? A team of researchers recently set out to learn if burnout impacted a firefighter’s ability to follow required safe work practices.

firefighters walking away in PPE after a fire

Clean gear is the new badge of honor

Posted: April 5, 2018

This article looks at firefighter perceptions of dirty gear and how Palm Beach County Fire Rescue promoted organizational resilience to combat the risk of firefighter cancer from dirty gear.

firefighter undergoing vo2 max testing

Testing for metabolic syndrome in firefighters

Posted: Dec. 21, 2017

Results of a recent study to see whether resting heart rate and heart rate reserve could be reliable predictors of metabolic syndrome in firefighters when VO2 max testing is not available.

suburban neighborhood

Identifying community fire risk using geographic mapping

Posted: Dec. 14, 2017

Researchers using GIS software evaluated a local fire safety intervention program to see if the residents selected for the program were actually living in areas with the highest fire risk. Here’s what they found.

fire extinguisher

38 million Kidde fire extinguishers recalled

Posted: Nov. 6, 2017

Kidde has announced a recall of almost 38 million fire extinguishers. They may not work during a fire emergency if they become clogged and require a lot of force to use.

firefighters wearing PPE

PPE use and unsafe actions by firefighters

Posted: Sept. 28, 2017

What causes firefighters to take unsafe actions related to personal protective equipment (PPE) use — even though they know they should be doing the opposite? A team of researchers led by Drexel University’s Center for Firefighter Injury Research and Safety Trends recently set out to understand why this occurs and what the fire service can do to fix it.

EMS workers treating a patient at a protest

Violence against EMS responders

Posted: Aug. 31, 2017

Findings from a research project that investigated injuries to paramedics and emergency medical technicians from patient-initiated violence.